What are the five freedoms protected by the First Amendment?
Religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition.
What item did students wear to protest the Vietnam War in Tinker v. Des Moines?
Black armbands.
What Supreme Court case established the rule for school-sponsored student newspapers?
Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier.
What two religious protections are found in the First Amendment?
The Establishment Clause and the Free Exercise Clause.
In Texas v. Johnson, what was the expressive conduct at issue?
Burning the American Flag.
What is expressive conduct? Give one example.
An action that communicates a message, such as wearing an armband, refusing to stand, or burning a flag.
What is the name of the test established by Tinker?
The substantial disruption test.
Name one legitimate teaching concern that might justify editing a school-sponsored newspaper.
Privacy, age-appropriate content, fairness, accuracy, or writing quality.
What religious text was posted in Kentucky classrooms in Stone v. Graham?
The 10 Commandments
In Everson v. Board of Education, why did the Court uphold New Jersey's program to reimburse bus fares for alll students, including those who attended public school?
Bus fare is a universal safety benefit, like fire protection. The state must be neutral, not hostile, to religion.
What did the Supreme Court rule in West Virginia v. Barnette about the Pledge of Allegiance?
Public schools cannot force students to salute the flag or recite the Pledge.
🎉 DAILY DOUBLE! 🎉
How many points will you wager?
Minimum wager - 100points
Maximum wager - your team's current score or 500 points, whichever is greater.
Give one example of expressive conduct that is likely protected speech and one example of expressive conduct that is likely not protected speech (try to come up with new examples, not just examples from the cases)
A student publishes an independent opinion on a personal T-shirt. Which test generally applies: Tinker or Hazelwood?
Tinker, because it is the student's personal expression.
What case struck down a state-written prayer recited in public schools, even though participation was voluntary?
Engel v. Vitale.
In the case Wisconsin v. Yoder, what did the Court rule regarding the religious freedom of Amish parents? Does this holding extend to other faiths?
The Court allowed Amish parents to withdraw their children from school after eighth grade. No, this holding was specifically for Amish parents, not other religions.
In Texas v. Johnson, why was burning the American flag protected?
It was expressive political conduct, and the government cannot prohibit an idea simply because it is offensive.
In Melton v. Young, why was the school allowed to prohibit a Confederate flag patch?
The school had documented racial fights, providing concrete evidence to reasonably forecast substantial disruption.
A principal removes a poorly researched article from a school-sponsored newspaper because it contains serious factual errors. Is this likely permitted under Hazelwood? Why?
Yes. Accuracy and quality are legitimate pedagogical concerns, assuming the decision is reasonably related to them.
Secular purpose, a primary effect that neither advances nor inhibits religion, and no excessive government entanglement with religion.
Lee v. Weisman; coercion or pressure on students to participate in a religious exercise.
In the case Zelman v. Simmons-Harris, where community members sued the city for providing school vouchers in which parents could choose which school to use them for, what was the Court's ruling and why?
The Court upheld school vouchers because parents independently chose where to use them, including religious schools. The program was neutral, available to all, and was based on individual choice.
Name two types of speech that receive little or no First Amendment protection.
Examples include true threats, incitement to imminent lawless action, obscenity, and speech used to commit fraud.
Fill in the blank: Students don't "_______________ at the schoolhouse gate." Tinker v. Des Moines, 1969, 7–2
shed their constitutional rights
🎉 DAILY DOUBLE! 🎉
How many points will you wager?
Minimum wager - 100points
Maximum wager - your team's current score or 500 points, whichever is greater.
Provide one example of when Tinker would be applied and one example of when Hazelwood would apply when it comes to student's writing an article. Why does that case apply to the example and the other does not?
Under the Lemon test, name its three requirements.
Secular purpose, a primary effect that neither advances nor inhibits religion, and no excessive government entanglement with religion.
A school requires teachers to read a statement promoting intelligent design as an alternative to evolution. Which case from the unit is most similar?
Kitzmiller v. Dover, which struck down an intelligent-design statement.