Contact Sports
Hallowed Grounds (for PJ)
Step by Step,
Shoe by Shoe
PJ or Nah?
Pre-Midterms
100

In its landmark 1945 decision Intn'l Shoe, the Supreme Court introduced these two considerations for deciding whether specific Jx satisfies due process.

What are minimum contacts with the forum and traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice?

100

In Pennoyer, D was served by publication, and his Oregon land was sold to satisfy a default judgment. This fact about when OR seized the land explains why it couldn’t justify Jx in the original suit.

What is OR first seized the land after entering judgment? 

To base Jx on the land, the court had to bring it under its control at the start of the suit.

100

Under the territorial rule in Pennoyer, a state could exercise PJ over a nonresident by personally serving the defendant _____.

Within the forum state.

One could also base Jx on property located within state borders at the outset of the suit, if judgment = limited to property. D was served by publication, and OR seized his land only after entering judgment. Neither basis supported the judgment.

100

A Nevada resident visits Sacramento for a wedding. While she’s there, she’s personally served with a California lawsuit over a car accident that happened in Nevada.

PJ — Burnham. She was voluntarily in California when she was personally served.

100

Before mid-terms, we had no idea this color would wave as hard as it did.

200

In this case, Delaware asserted Jx by abstractly deeming stock to be located in the state. Supreme Court held that Intn'l Shoe min contacts test still applied.

What is Shaffer (v. Heitner)? DE treated shares as located in forum because Greyhound incorporated there. Supreme Court held that min contacts test applies even w/ seizing property. D's contacts w/ DE ≠ sufficient, and shares ≠ related to claim, so quasi in-rem Jx did not stand.

200

In Mallory, Pennsylvania could rely on this basis after an out-of-state corporation registered under a law expressly subjecting registered corporations to suit on any claim.

What is consent by registration?

While this statutory basis for consent by waiver is still not fully decided, the Mallory rule is about business registration and should be analyzed as such.

200

Intn'l Shoe added that an out-of-state defendant must have (1.)_____ with the forum such that maintaining the suit does not offend (2.) _____.

1. Minimum contacts. 

2. Traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.

D's salespeople regularly solicited orders in Washington, and the state’s claim for unemployment contributions arose from their work there, despite their home in STL.

200

A bike shop sells and advertises exclusively in Oregon. A customer buys a bike there, takes it to California, and crashes when the brakes fail. The customer sues the shop in California.

No PJ – WWVW. The buyer’s unilateral decision brought the bike into California. The shop served the Oregon market.

200

Under Rule 12______, a D may move to dismiss a claim for “failure to ______ upon which ______.”

Fill in all 3 blanks.

1.) 12(b)(6).

2.) State a claim.

3.) Relief can be granted.

The court favorably assumes the complaint’s well-pleaded factual allegations are true and asks whether those facts plausibly show that P is legally entitled to relief.

300

In this case, CA could exercise Jx over a FL writer and editor whose allegedly defamatory article focused on a CA actress and her career there.

What is Calder (v. Jones)? 

The article drew on CA sources and focused on the actress’ CA career. CA contacts: D's aimed the story, magazine had largest circulation, and P suffered most reputational harm there.

300

In Ford, the cars in question were first sold outside the states where they later crashed. This fact about Ford’s business in those states helped establish specific Jx anyway.

What is Ford marketed, sold, and serviced the same models in the states where the crashes occurred? 

That tied the claims to Ford’s forum contacts even though the original sales took place elsewhere.

300

WWVW added that relevant foreseeability concerns whether D's conduct and connection with the forum are such that it should reasonably anticipate _____ there.

Being haled into court.

P's unilateral conduct is not sufficient to est. PJ in a forum, even if the injury occurred there. The car reached OK because the buyers drove it there after purchasing it from the dealer in NY.


300

An Illinois company makes space heaters in Illinois, sells the same model in California and Nevada. Several California buyers sue the company in California after their heaters catch fire there. A Nevada buyer joins the suit. She bought her heater in Nevada and was injured when it caught fire there. Does California have PJ for her claim?

No PJ — Bristol-Myers Squibb. Specific jurisdiction is assessed claim by claim. The Nevada buyer’s purchase, use, and injury all occurred in Nevada. The California buyers’ injuries explain why their own claims belong in California.

300

Under Rule 26(b)(1), what 3 requirements must information meet to fall within the ordinary scope of discovery?

What are 1.) nonprivileged, 2.) relevant to any party’s claim/defense, and 3.) proportional to the needs of the case?

Information within that scope can be discovered even if it would be inadmissible at trial.


400

These two justices wrote competing stream-of-commerce opinions in Asahi. 1: Awareness of regular flow of products there = sufficient contacts, and 2: additional conduct aimed at forum needed for PJ. 

Who are Justices 1. William Brennan & 2. Sandra Day O’Connor, respectively?

400

Barring exceptions, these are all grounds that can give a state court PJ even when the claim is unrelated to the forum, up modern day.

What are 

1. being at home in the forum (Goodyear & Daimler), 

2. tag service (Burnham), and 

3. consent/waiver (Mallory)?

400

In McGee, a single insurance policy supported specific Jx because the contract had a 1.)_____ connection with CA. The Court also stressed CA's interest in giving residents an effective way to 2.)_____ when nonresidents refuse to pay.


1.) Substantial.

2.) Recover.

The nonresident's policy was delivered in CA, and the insured mailed premiums from there. CA was interested in protecting its residents in its forum.

400

A French climbing harness maker promotes its gear at trade shows in Montana and sells nationwide through an independent distributor there. The distributor makes a single Ohio climbing gym sale. That harness tears during a climb there, and the injured climber sues the maker in Ohio.

No PJ, but kinda both — McIntyre. Kennedy's plurality looked for conduct aimed at the forum state itself. Breyer’s concurrence took a narrower approach: single, isolated sale = insufficient. Ginsburg's dissent: nationwide targeting = fair notice in any state of injury

400

Under Rule 15(a)(2), once a party can no longer amend as a matter of course, what are the two ways they can amend their pleading?

What are 1.) opposing party’s written consent or 2.) the court’s leave?

The court should freely give leave when justice so requires.

500

In this 2014 case, Supreme Court held that knowing where Ps would feel the harm was insufficient by itself to establish D's min contacts with that state.

What is (Walden v. Fiore)? 

Federal agent seized P's cash in GA, allegedly drafted a false affidavit to justify it. He knew D's had ties to NV, where they felt loss. But connection between D's conduct and forum ≠ satisfied b/c agent’s only link to NV came through the travelers. NV lacked PJ.

500

During WWII, a Philippine mining company’s president ran the company from Ohio. In this exceptional case, Supreme Court held that due process allowed OH to hear a claim unrelated to D's forum activities.

What is (Perkins v. Benguet Consolidated Mining Co.)? 

Ohio served as company’s temp HQ, which supported general Jx there as its "nerve center."

500

Burger King outlined 5 fairness factors for PJ, which consider 1.) burden on the defendant, 2.) forum state’s interest in hearing the dispute, and 3.)_____, 4.)_____, and 5.)_____.

3.) P's interest in convenient/effective relief.

4.) Interstate judicial system's interest in efficient resolution.

5.) States’ shared interest in advancing substantive social policies.

Court upheld FL's Jx over nonresident D in dispute re: unpaid fees b/c he had deliberately entered a 20yr relationship with P's Miami HQ + failed to show FL litigation ≠ reasonable

500

A Maine radio network signs deals with stations across the U.S. to air its weekly show. In an episode broadcast in NY, the host accuses a Vermont chef of stealing charity donations. The chef says the accusation is false and sues the network for defamation in NY.

PJ — Keeton. The network deliberately reached NY listeners through its broadcast agreements. The episode that aired there is the basis of the chef’s claim.

500

A judge believes P's lawyer filed a motion to harass D's side. Neither party has requested sanctions. How can P still be sanctioned by the court, if necessary?

What is a show-cause order? 

The judge must identify the specific conduct that appears to violate Rule 11(b) and give P's lawyer a court-discretion window of opportunity to respond, by either withdrawing or rectifying violation, or explaining why they did not violate the rule.

M
e
n
u