Dates
Even though it's a 1/365 chance, Matt and Erin share THIS holiday together
What is their birthdays?
THIS-colored shell spells doom for whoever's in first place
What is blue?
You've cat to be kitten me right meow: before my mom had Trouble, she had THIS tabby who shared a name with one of my cousins?
What is Jake?
This fifth-grade situation was pretty fishy, because Oscar had a crush on THIS girl, too
Who is Aurelia?
Also known as National Buttermilk Biscuit Day, THIS is the date of the wedding next year
What is May 14th, 2022?
Smaller than most courses, Baby Park has not the typical three laps, but THIS number
What is seven?
What is Freschetta?
Matt's initial life plan was to write comics that THIS early OLMC crush would illustrate
Who is Audrey?
Matt and Erin's one-year anniversary date has been hard to beat due to celebrating it in THIS beautiful city, which is also a tourist destination
What is Malaga?
If you've REALLY made a bad turn in a race, you might have to press THIS button to back things up
What is B?
If Ian and Oscar and coming over, my mom would try to have THESE THREE ITEMS stocked up in the kitchen?
What are Oreos, Sun Chips, and Nesquik?
Who would've guessed it? Brian was the first of us to date no other than THIS OLMC lady
Who is Mallory?
Matt and Erin enjoyed their first date at THIS fine eating establishment, which closed weeks after they went
What is Metro Diner?
This item, which makes Matt think of a funny Finding Nemo quote (and isn't actually an available item in the GameCube version) obscures the vision of your opponents
What is ink?
Much of the kitchen was remodeled a few years ago, but THIS appliance remains the original when the house was built in the '80s
What is the microwave?
THIS large-earlobed lass was the recipient of Matt's love in seventh grade
Who is Taylor?
What is vomiting/dry heaving?
The babies have Chain Chomp and DK has a giant banana. King Boo and Petey Piranha are different by having THIS item as their special
What are all possible special items?
Even though it's actually pretty old, THIS is the newest piece of furniture in the basement
What is that one end table thingie?
THIS lady confirmed herself as Matt's first girlfriend using blue ink
Who is Kayley?