Mishnah
Abaye & Rav Idi
Rabbi Zeira Case
Korbanos
Shomer to Shomer
100

Who borrowed the cow from the שוכר?

The שואל

100

Who asked "במאי קני להאי פרה" - "with what does he aquire this cow?"

רב אידי בר אבין

100

How many days was the original שכירות

100 days

100

If a false oath does not deny money, which korban is brought?

חטאת

100

Who says שומר שמסר לשומר is פטור?

רב

200

How did the cow die?

 מתה כדרכה

200

Who answered him?

אביי

200

After renting the cow for 100 days, how many days did the owner borrow it back?


90 days

200

If a false oath denies money, which korban is brought?

אשם

200

Who says שומר שמסר לשומר is חייב?

רבי יוחנן

300

According to תנא קמא, who pays who?

The שואל pays the שוכר

300

When does the שוכר really take ownership according to אביי?

When the cow dies

300

During which period did the cow die?

During the final 70-day שאלה

300

?מתה כדרכה and they said נאנסה. What do both bring

חטאת

300

According to Rav, why is he פטור?

Because he gave it to a competent person

400

According to רבי יוסי, who pays who?

the שואל pays the בעל הבית

400

Why does the שוכר still swear if he acquires it from the cow dying?

 To appease the mind of the owner

400

Why does רבי זירא say the owner owes more than one cow even though there was only one original cow?

Because there were two separate acts of שאלה

400

Which korban do they both bring if it was נגנבה and they said מתה מחמת מלאכה?

אשם

400

According to רבי יוחנן, what claim can the owner make?

I don't want my object in someone else's possession 

500

What is רבי יוסי reasoning?

How can the שוכר do business with his friends cow? 

500

What does "דל אנת ודל שבועתך ואנא משתעינא דינא בהדי שואל" mean? 

Take yourself and take your shvuah, I'll go to judgment with the shoel

500

According to רבי זירא, how many total claims does the שוכר have against the owner when the cow dies during the final שאלה?

There are four claims (two שאלה claims and two שכירות claims)

500

Which Amora organized all four korban cases?

רבי ירמיה

500

According to Abaye, even if a שומר חנם gave it to a שומר שכר, according to רבי יוחנן he is still what?

חייב

M
e
n
u