Top Picks
What was Alexis' Top Album of the Year?
American Teen
Rating: 10
What category did Julia rate the highest?
Soundtrack of an era of your life
Her average rating for this category was 8.95 out of 10. Every album in this theme received a high score from her, including:
Demonstrating a clear group consensus, this Patti Smith album was so disliked that no single reviewer rated it higher than a 3.75 out of 10.
Horses
What category received the lowest rankings?
Taylor Inspired
While this category included some highly-rated albums like Harry Styles (which averaged over 9.0), it also contained two of the most poorly-rated albums in the entire document: Blue by Joni Mitchell (average rating of 4.0) and Horses by Patti Smith (average rating of 3.05). These very low scores brought down the overall average for the category, making it the lowest-ranked theme week.
What album of Kiera's received a 1/10 from one of the roomie's?
The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan
Alexis's Rating: 1/10
What was Charlotte's Top Album of the Year?
SOS
Melodrama
The Fame Monster
I'm The Problem
The Stranger
Man's Best Friend
Rating: 9.5
What was Charlotte's #1 song of 2025?
Blame Brett
Hannah's worst album pick
Blue by Joni Mitchell
What album received a 5 from Julia, Charlotte, and Alexis?
Blonde - Frank Ocean
What was the oldest album selected?
The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan
What was Julia's Top Album of the Year?
Riot
Rating: 10
What song was every roomie's #1 from the Who's Next album?
Baba O'Riley
Alexis's worst album pick
Blonde by Frank Ocean
What was in every roomie's top 3 songs from the "Blue" by Joni Mitchell?
Carey
What was the first and last album selected for 2025?
SOS (SZA - Char)
I Barely Know Her (Sombr - Char)
What was Hannah's Top Album of the Year?
Melodrama
The Lumineers
AM
The Stranger
Rating: 9.5
What category was the highest-rated overall?
Car Ride Sing Along
Average of 8.0 or higher!
What was the second lowest ranked album of 2025?
The Freewheelin Bob Dylan
This reviewer showed a trend of rating albums lower than the rest of the group, giving scores of 5.5 or less to popular albums like Riot!, Songs About Jane, and AM.
What album lived rent free in Alexis's head this year?
In Between Dreams - Jack Johnson
What was Kiera's Top Album of the Year?
The Stranger
Rating: 10
The Stranger by Billy Joel
What was the lowest rated album of 2025?
Horses (Patti Smith)
What album had no honorable mentions?
Horses by Patti Smith
For Melancholy Brunettes (& sad women) by Japanese Breakfast
Name all categories for the 2025 Album Review Season (minus Free for Alls)