Input vs. Output
What's the Proxy or Measure?
Proxy Dimensions
100

This looks at the results of the audit and attempts to measure the level of audit quality delivered

What is an output-based measure?

100

This is the name for correcting and re-issuing financial statements after they have already been published.

What is a restatement?

100

Severity of the misconduct implied by the measure

What is Egregiousness?

200

This looks at observable choices clients make before/independent of the outcome

What is an input-based measure?

200

This is the audit opinion that signals the auditor's doubt about whether the company can keep operating.

What is a going-concern (GC) opinion?

200

Discreteness, Consensus on the Measurement, and Measurement Error

What are Measurement Issues?

300

This measure cannot be evaluated based on directness.

What is an input-based measure?

300

Statistical estimate of how much management artificially inflated earnings using accounting guesswork

What are discretionary accruals (DAC)?

300

Perception-based Measure

What is Perceived Quality?

400

Used to study auditor supply and client demand.

What are an output-based measure and an input-based measure?

400

This is the simple, most commonly used input proxy for auditor size. 

What is Big N (membership)?

400

Extent to which the auditor influences, controls or is responsible for the output (only applies to outputs)

What is directness?

500

Market-Based Proxies

What is an output-based measure?

500

ERCs, Stock Market Reactions to audit events, cost of capital (D/E), and auditor-client market share

What are perception-based measures?

500

Behind closed doors, a dedicated auditor spends dozens of unbilled hours tracing obscure inventory discrepancies, ultimately forcing a client to fix a hidden material misstatement before the financial statements are released.

What is Actual Quality?

M
e
n
u