1986
Marty Barrett
Bonus: how was the out made
strike out
double bonus By whom
Jesse Orosco/Gary Carter
Yankee (2024) and Mets (2025)
Juan Soto
New York Met who grew up in Wyoming
Brandon Nimmo
Padres 2006 Dodgers 1992-1998
Mike Piazza
2020 NL 3rd place
Jacob DeGrom
2002
Kenny Loften
Yankee from 1946-1963 before joining the Mets in 1965
Yogi Berra
2021 Yankee Right Fielder
Aaron Judge
Dodger 2018
Padre 2019-2025
Manny Machado
2022 AL 2nd Place
Dylan Cease
2005
Orlando Palmeiro
Bonus How was the out made
ground ball
double bonus by whom
shortstop Juan Uribe
helped the Mets win the 1986 World Series and the Yankees in 1996 and 1999
Darryl Strawberry
2021 Mets Pitcher All Star
Not Jacob DeGrom
Taijuan Walker
Dodgers 1969-1972
Padres 1975-1977
Bobby Valentine
Hint: Later turned manager
2023 AL Winner
Gerrit Cole
2024
Alex Verdugo
New York Yankees (2022–2023)
New York Mets (2024)
Harrison Bader
2022 Yankee All Star Player who was 27 years old
Andrew Benintendi
Dodger 2017
Padre 2021-2024
Yu Darvish
Hint Pitcher
2021 and 2024 2nd place
Zach Wheeler
1943
Debs Garms
First Player to play for the Yankees(1955 season and again from 1958 to 1959) and the Mets (1962)
Marv Throneberry
2 of the 3 starting pitchers who were on the 2023 Mets but not 2025
Max Scherzer
Justin Verlander
Carlos Carrasco
Padre 2004-2007
Dodger 2007
David Wells
2024 NL 3rd place
Paul Skenes