Great Player. Bad habits
Everyone loved this guy in Miami. I'm sure Jeter traded him because he doesn't eat Kit Kats right.
Giancarlo Stanton
Yadier Molina (I'm bias, ok?)
9
The movie probably showed everything wrong that can happen with a name like "Indians", so now they're going to be this.... boring name next year
Guardians
He ain't gonna win the NL Cy Young again this year, that's for sure.
Trevor Bauer
MLB The Show 2008
Ryan Howard
Look. Batters don't hit the ball right back down the middle on purpose. You're a favorite for the rookie of the year, on a struggling Royals team. But he still needs to gripe at Mike Trout
Ivan Rodriguez
13
Clue Haywood, the Triple Crown winner in the movie, was actually played by Pete Vuckovich, who was a Cy Young winner for this team in 1982
Milwaukee Brewers
Famous anti vaxer, and the best player of all time never to make an All Star team. And possible will make the HoF.
Andrelton Simmons
MLB the Show 09
Dustin Pedroia
If this player drew a line in the dirt where the pitch was that you called a strike, you KNOW you're wrong.
Ichiro Suzuki
Gregg Maddux
18
Harry Doyle, the Indians announcer in the movie, actually announces for this team
Milwaukee Brewers
Luis Gonzalez
MLB the Show 2007
David Wright
You're up by 7. The count is 3-0. The pitcher throws a ball that ends up in the opposing batter's box, but he was already walking to 1st before the pitch even came. He also has a problem with phones.
David Ortiz
Paul Goldschmidt
3
Before the Indians "won" the pennant in Major League II, their last pennant was in this year.
1954
Despite being on 2 MLB the show covers in a row, his contract kept the Twins from doing.... anything
Joe Mauer
MLB the Show 18
Baby Shark. The player hasn't done anything wrong, I just hate that song.
Gerardo Parra.
Johnny Bench
10
Rick "Wild Thing" Vaugn, Charlie Sheen, is actually not an Indians fan. But, he does like baseball, and this team.
Cincinnatti Reds
One to Rollins, And the Phillies have ended the Braves season, off a double play ball hit by this player.
Freddie Freeman
MLB the Show 13
Andrew McCutchen