'Dark' arguments
"Not so Dark" arguments
100
Era was more about day-to-day struggle for existence than artistic creativity, intellectual thought, scholarship. No great ideas and no great art!
Literary darkness.
100
Monastic life inspired illuminated manuscripts, metalwork. (Ireland: c. 500-700' s).
Also historical writings of Bedel. Also "heroic" lit. - Beowulf (Anglo-Saxon), Tain Bo Cualnge (Celtic), Song of Roland (Frankish)
200
prevailed. Post-Roman political mayhem and disorder 5th thru 8th centuries, followed by Vikings and Magyars in 9th and io" centuries.
battle-axe anarchy
200
Charlemagne era in 8th century revived universal empire concept. Two Germanic tribes -
Franks & Angleshad produced sizable states in France and England by the later 10th century.
300
The moral standards of the clergy declined - bishops/abbots/popes had concubines, slaves, armor, swords, drank heavily. No great churches were built.
Christianity was barbarized!
300
Pacifying effect of Christianity -
Saints developed as role models of moral perfection. Monks demonstrated hard work & scholarship as a virtue. Church was the best organized political force: the agent of cultural unity. Europe in medieval times meant Christendom.
400
Roads deteriorated; barter replaced money; towns declined. Trade was local. Subsistence farming. Compared to five centuries of "camping out"!
Economic life regressed.
400
Monasteries were also market centers. Other trade revival evidence -
(I) in the Mediterranean: rise of Venice from 7th century; (II) in North Atlantic world: Viking towns & Norse maritime empire; (III) on fertile manors: some agricultural improvements by 1000. 1 Bede's
M
e
n
u