Expertise-oriented
Consumer-oriented
Program-oriented
Decision-Oriented
Participant-oriented
100
Providing professional judgement of quality
What is the focus of expertise-oriented evaluation?
100
Judging quality of products to aid decisions about purchases
What is the focus of consumer-oriented evaluation?
100
determining the extent to which program objectives or key elements in the program theory are delivered or archieved
What is the focus of program-oriented evaluation?
100
providing useful information to aid in making decisions
What is the focus of decision-oriented evaluation?
100
involving many stakeholders or a few stakeholders in depth in the evaluation
What is the focus of participant-oriented evaluation?
200
Basing judgement on individual knowledge and experiences
What is the characteristics of Expertise-oriented evaluation?
200
Using criterion checklists to analyze products
What is the characteristics of consumer-based evaluation?
200
focus on identifying and describing key elements of program and why it should work
What is the characteristics of program-based evaluation?
200
serving rational decision making, evaluating at all stages of program development
What is the characteristics of decision-based evaluation?
200
reflecting multiple realities, intensive involvement with stakeholders and understanding the context
What is the characteristics of participant-based evaluation?
300
Criticism, self study, accreditation, blue-ribbon panels
What component does expertise-oriented uses?
300
consumer reports, product development, selection of products for dissemenation
What component does consumer-oriented uses?
300
program planning and development, adding to knowledge
What component does program-oriented uses?
300
program development, organization's management systems
What component does decision-oriented uses?
300
smaller evaluations, focus can be on process use and organizational learning
What component does participant-oriented uses?
400
subjective criticism as a form of discipline inquiry; self-study with outside verification; standard
What are the contribution of expertise-evaluation?
400
Articulating criteria, using checklists; formative-summative purposes; bias control
What are the contribution of expertise-evaluation?
400
considering program theory and link between program activities and outcome
What are the contribution of program-evaluation?
400
link evaluation to decisions, work closely with managers to identify decisions and to learnt about the context in which decisions are made
What are the contribution of decision-evaluation?
400
emergent evaluation designs, using stakeholders to improve use
What are the contribution of participant-oriented evaluation?
500
applicable to many areas; efficiency (easy of implementation, timing)
What are the strength of expertise-evaluation?
500
emphasis on consumer information needs, developing checklists, influence on product developers, concern with cost-effectiveness and utility
What are the strength of consumer-evaluation?
500
prompts link to program creators and to research literature, helps explain program outcome
What are the strength of program-evaluation?
500
potentially comprehensive, sensitive to information needs of those in leadership proposition or who will use evaluation
What are the strength of decision-evaluation?
500
pluralistic, focus on decscription and judgement
What are the strength of expertise-evaluation?
M
e
n
u