Putting Witnesses on Stand
Requirement that witness states: she does not remember the answer to the question and seeing the writing will “refresh” her recollection
What is needed before a document can be used to refresh a witness's memory?
Show impaired perception or memory; Demonstrate inconsistencies; Attack a witness’s character for truthfulness
What are some grounds for impeachment?
Non-extrinsic evidence on a non-collateral matter related to a witness's prior inconsistent statements
What is the preferred way for attorneys to introduce evidence of a witness's prior inconsistent statements?
The subject of direct examination and witness credibility
What is the scope of cross-examination?
(General rule)
When an examining attorney must ask the witness whether the writing has refreshed their recollection.
What is after the witness has looked at the writing?
Any party may attack the credibility of any witness (hint: true or false)
What is true - the basic premise under the federal rules of evidence for impeaching witnesses?
Extrinsic evidence
What is anything other than (external to) the witness's testimony?
Questions that are allowed when necessary to develop the witness’s testimony and/or in response to a hostile witness or adverse party
What are leading questions?
The person (party) who can introduce a writing used to refresh recollection into evidence regardless of admissibility
What is the adverse party?
A witness who has a reason to testify in favor of or against a party
What is a witness's potential bias?
Extrinsic evidence on a collateral matter related to a witness’s prior inconsistent statements.
What is the least preferred (prohibited) method for how attorneys can introduce evidence of a witness's prior inconsistent statements?
Questions that suggest a certain answer and undermine witness credibility and personal knowledge
What are leading questions?
The purpose(s) for which a jury can use a writing that was used to refresh a witness's memory
What is to assess the witness's credibility?
Asking a witness questions for the purpose of "finishing the story."
What is a common tactic of impeachment?
Discrepancies between a witness’s courtroom statements and statements she made outside of the courtroom.
What is the definition of prior inconsistent statements?
Witness perception, memory and recall (narration).
What is needed to establish personal knowledge?
The person (party) who decides when an attorney can use a document to refresh a witness's memory
What is the judge?
A attorney who attempts to impeach a witness is creating doubt about that person's credibility (hint: true or false)
What is true - a basic premise of the federal rules of evidence for impeachment?
A matter that is only relevant to a fact in evidence since it just attacks a witness’s credibility and does not help establish a fact of consequence.
What is a collateral matter?