Citations
Davis v. Karolek
Persuasive Arguments
Icebreaker
Oral Arguments
100

Spot the mistake: Id at 27.

What is..."Id.” must be italicized and include a period

100

These are the 3 things a plaintiff must prove to make a prima facie case

What is...

1. Plaintiff belongs to the protected class

2. Plaintiff sought accommodation, and the employer did not accommodate her 

3. Employer did accommodate others “similar in their ability or inability to work” 

100

A method to help your reader see your organization by explicitly stating how the argument ahead is organized

What is..a roadmap

100

You should avoid sitting shotgun on an eight hour roadtrip with this person

Who is...Annie

100

This is the intro phrase to an oral argument.

What is... Your honor, and may it please the court.

200

In a full case citation, this formatting rule applies to the court and year information

What is...placing it in parentheses

200

Spell the name of the virus in this case

What is...Oropouche

200

Efficiency, administration of justice, separation of powers, and appropriate allocation of power between states and the federal

What is... Examples of Substantive Law and Its Underlying Policy Themes

200

This person is most likely to get away with murder

Who is...Emma

200

This is the third step to the introduction in an oral argument 

What is...provide aroadmap of the argument for the court 

300

Spot the mistake: Smith v. Jones, 555 U.S. 123, (2010).

What is...there should be no comma before the parenthetical. Smith v. Jones, 555 U.S. 123 (2010).

300

This is the binding law in this case.

What is...Title VII, 42 U.S.C. § 2000e(k)

300

The following is an example of what persuasive technique: “The Sixth Circuit has previously recognized adherence to a uniformly applied policy as a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason. See Tysinger v. Police Dept. of City of Zanesville, 463 F.3d 569 (6th Cir. 2006)”

What is...

• Persuasion through Citations

• Emphasize Weight of Authority of Citation

• Ethos


300

You would not want this person in your band (yet)

Who is... Jamahl

300

The introduction for your oral argument should not go longer than ____ seconds 

What is... 60 seconds

400

This abbreviation must be used for "Second Series" when citing to older federal and regional reporters

What is..."2d"

400

Eduardo Berto is in this type of therapy

What is...whirlpool therapy

400

The attorney for Karolek chooses to write the following: "According to Davis, she was discriminated against by Karolek…”. It previously said: "According to Davis, Karolek discriminated against her…”.

What is... strategic use of passive voice

400

This person has a dog you would avoid on the street 

Who is...Alex

400

Responses to judges' questions should always be framed in a way that is...

What is... Direct or Persuasive

500

Spot the mistake: U.S. Const., Art. II, § 3.

What is...extra comma after “Const.” that doesn’t belong. U.S. Const. Art. II, § 3.

500

This person is the notary public in the case

Who is...Shane Kirby

500

This is an example of what persuasive technique: 

• Karolek’s brief says: “Once the plaintiff has made out a prima facie case, the burden of production shifts to the employer, and the employer must offer a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for denying her accommodation. Young, 575 U.S. at 229.”

• Davis’s brief says: If the plaintiff can meet her burden to make out the prima facie case, the burden of production then shifts to the employer to offer a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for denying her accommodation. Young, 575 U.S. at 229.”

What is...drafting a rule from the client's perspective

500

This person wore muddy boots to school until 5th grade

Who is... Anna

500

A trial court judge would be most concerned about hearing these two things 

What is...

1. The existing governing law 

2. How the facts apply to that law

M
e
n
u