AL/NL Cy Young
2023
AL: Gerrit Cole
NL: Blake Snell
I won the 2012 MVP Award. I am now the President of Baseball Operations for my former team.
Buster Posey
I hit 659 home runs for the Yankees. I have many iconic nicknames.
George Herman Ruth
I am a two way sensation that goes by the nickname "ShoTime"
Shohei Ohtani
Whit Merrifield (2 Teams)
Atlanta Braves and Philadelphia Phillies
2021
AL: Robbie Ray
NL: Corbin Burnes
I spent my entire career with on team and I'm considered the best defensive catcher of my era. The team that I spent my career with is named after an animal.
Yadier Molina
I spent 18 years playing for the Yankees and 1 year playing for the Mets. I also managed each team to a pennant (1964 and 1973)
Yogi Berra
I am one of two players to win MVP in their rookie season.
Ichiro Suzuki
Martin Maldonado
Chicago White Sox
2019
AL: Justin Verlander
NL: Jacob deGrom
I won MVP in 2009 when I hit .365. I was recently inducted into the Hall Of Fame.
Joe Mauer
Name both SNY and YES Networks iconic TV Play by Play Announcers
I was born in Canada but chose to represent Team Dominican Republic in the World Baseball Classic in 2023, had it not been for a knee injury.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Chris Paddack
Minnesota Twins
2015
AL: Dallas Keuchel
NL: Jake Arrieta
I finished 4th in MVP voting in 2014 and I'm a 2x All Star for an NL Central team.
Jonathan Lucroy
Despite only playing there for 3 seasons, I hold the Mets single season records in Batting Average (.354) and wRC+ (167). I also played briefly with the Yankees in one of my later years.
John Olerud
I was a Cy Young Finalist in 2024 and represented team Puerto Rico in the 2017 World Baseball Classic.
Seth Lugo
James Paxton (2 Teams)
Los Angeles Dodgers and Boston Red Sox
2012
AL: David Price
NL: R.A. Dickey
I was caught jacking off in a parking lot and was arrested.
Reese McGuire
I managed the Yankees to 7 World Series Titles. I was also the first manager in Mets history.
Casey Stengel
I won three consecutive Sawamura Awards (Japanese Cy Young) from 2021-2023 and signed a record breaking MLB contract.
Yoshinobu Yamamoto
Martin Perez (2 Teams)
Pittsburgh Pirates and San Diego Padres