NYY Cup of Coffee
Diamondbacks (2011-2018)
Cardinals (2019-2024)
Yankees (2025-2026)
7x All-Star, 2022 NL MVP, 4x GG, 63.9 WAR
Paul Goldschmidt
Starting Pitcher, 8x All-Star, played primarily for Angels and Astros, 5714 career strikeouts, 83.6 career WAR
Nolan Ryan (1966-1993)
Flame throwing closer who was traded at 2025 deadline to Padres in exchange for a mountain of prospects including No.3 prospect Leo De Vries.
Mason Miller
Player’s dad was 2004 AL MVP
This player is in the second year of his 14-yr/$500m dollar deal.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Cubs infielder who also played for the Astros and Red Sox
Alex Bregman
Brewers (2019-2024), Yankees (2025), Mets (2026)
Pitcher, 2x All-Star
Devin Williams
All-Star for Dodgers 81-82, Played primarily for Braves and Dodgers, 242 Home Runs, Coached the Giants, Cubs, Reds, Nats, and Astros.
Dusty Baker
Fan favorite who was traded to Yankees at 2024 deadline in exchange for Agustin Ramirez and other prospects.
This player has played 3B and 2B for the Yankees
Jazz Chisholm Jr.
2018 AL Cy Young and 2023 NL Cy Young
Plays on Dodgers
Blake Snell
Former batting champ who signed a 1-year deal with a Western based team
Luis Arraez
Pirates (2016-2019), Yankees (2021-2022), Cubs (2023-2026)
Starting Pitcher, 15.5 career WAR, led Yankees in wins in 2022 (14)
Jameson Taillon
Big name closer of 70s and 80s, 9x All-Star, 1978 WS champion
Rich (Goose) Gossage
Outfielder traded from Rays to Mariners at the 2024 deadline. All-Star for Seattle in 2025
Randy Arozarena
Middle infield defensive wizard with 3 gold gloves in 4 full seasons of play. 2025 was his first season with the Blue Jays after being acquired from Cleveland
Andres Gimenez
Veteran corner infielder who is returning to his old team with 326 home runs under his belt.
Eugenio Suarez
Mets (2017-2020), Guardians (2021-2023), Dodgers (2023, 2024), Rays (2024), Reds (2024), Nationals (2025), Yankees (2025-2026)
Utility Style Player, 10.3 career WAR
Amed Rosario
Orioles star with 504 home runs. Runner up MVP in 1982 and 1983. 8x AS, 3x GG, Hall of Fame.
Eddie Murray
Journeyman first baseman who was traded at 3 straight deadlines.
2022: Nationals to Padres (part of Soto trade)
2023: Guardians to Marlins
2024: Marlins to Diamondbacks
Currently on Minnesota, spent 2025 on Nationals
Josh Bell
13-year veteran who came up big for the Dodgers in the World Series. Plays the infield.
Miguel Rojas
Active stolen base leader who is a two-time All-Star (2016, 2022) signed late in the offseason with the Kansas City Royals. He is an outfielder
Starling Marte
Cardinals (2016-2018), Diamondbacks (2019-2022), Royals (2022), Reds & Mariners (2023), Yankees (2023-2025), Mets (2026)
Relief Pitcher, 3.2 career WAR
Luke Weaver
Starting Pitcher, 1984 Cy Young, Played primarily for Dodgers, Cubs, and Indians
Rick Sutcliffe
These four prospects were a part of the Juan Soto to the Padres deal. You have to name at least three
1. Current Nationals Shortstop
2. Third-year player who hit 31 HRs in 2025
3. Player who split time in 2025 with Red Wings and Nationals who mainly plays Centerfield
4. Southpaw who was an All-Star in 2025 and was traded to the Rangers in the offseason
CJ Abrams, James Wood, Robert Hassell, MacKenzie Gore
Young outfielder who played a key role in Toronto’s 2025 offensive and defensive plans. He played his first full season in 2025 and homered 12 times.
Nathan Lukes
Veteran who had a resurgent season with Seattle in 2025, hitting 26 homers. He cashed in with a 2-yr/$40m deal with the Mets.
Jorge Polanco