Precedential Facts
What did Fredrick's sign in Fredrick v. Morse say?
Bong Hits 4 Jesus
The snapchat case; the only one with off-campus speech
Mahanoy Area School District v. B.L.
The full versions of the CREAC acronym
Conclusion, Rule, Explanation, Application, Conclusion
Holding of Tinker
"materially and substantially interferes"
How Ava expressed her speech (what did she do, when, where)
via personal TikTok account, off-campus and not during school hours
The timeline in Tinker with speech and disruption
The students were suspended/disciplined before they even wore the armbands/before there was any disruption
Drugs are bad case
Morse v. Frederick
a Rule is similar to this in a case. *hint, it's the next category
a holding
Holding of Morse
prohibit student speech that can reasonably be interpreted as promoting illegal drug use
The possible connection between the school and Ava's TikTok
#abbotthigh
B.L. made her expletive comments where?
At home
Armbands; political protest
Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District
this section is where you say how the facts of your case are like/unlike a previous case
Application
Holding of Fraser
can punish speech with suspension if determined lewd, offensive, or disruptive to the school's basic educational mission
What happened in the school because of Ava's Tik Tok
Fraser did this before going ahead with his speech
Bonus: they told him not to give it
Innuendo-filled speech case
Bethel School District No. 403 v. Fraser
In Tinker, the student protestors were suspended for wearing peaceful armbands at the Supreme Court ruled that is a violation of their rights is an example of what type of CREAC section?
Holding of Hazelwood
editorial control over style and content of student speech in school-sponsored expressive activities allowed when reasonably related to legitimate educational concerns
Similar incident over this type of project two-years ago that caused an assembly during vital test prep time
In Hazelwood, why did the principal pull two page of the newspaper?
They had stories about teen pregnancy on them and he did not want them published. He thought they might cause bullying and did not feel it reflected the school's values.
School newspaper case
Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier
Why do we present arguments in the CREAC form?
It is easy to understand and has good flow
Holding of Mahanoy
off-campus speech protected in some circumstances; factors: 1) schools not standing in place of parents, 2) prohibiting students from certain types of speech altogether, 3) interest in protecting unpopular expression
Was there a disruption caused by Ava's actual in-school presentation?
No because she was not allowed to give it