Side Characters
Who sent Archer Story a letter saying they wanted to meet up?
Fred Baxter (McManus 153)
What is Jonah's real last name?
North (McManus 85)
Who is the father of Allison's baby?
Matt Ryan/Theresa's son (McManus 201)
Where does Milly bump into Jonah?
On the ferry/boat (McManus 30)
How does Jonah first describe Milly when he bumps into her?
"drop-dead gorgeous" (McManus 30)
Who unexpectedly shows up at the Summer Gala?
Anders Story/JT Story (McManus 217)
Which grandchild does Mildred Story ignore upon having lunch with them?
Milly (McManus 178)
What did Allison watch with Theresa when she was a teenager?
Baseball (McManus 95)
Where has Archer Story been hiding out since he got back to the island?
A bungalow behind Rob Valentine's house (McManus 143)
How does Milly figure out Jonah's secret?
Jonah North isn't allergic to seafood (McManus 78)
What did Archer Story choose as his fake name?
Chaz (McManus 142)
What does Aubrey say she hates about herself while trying on dresses for the Summer Gala?
Her arms/shoulders (McManus 186)
Who catches Allison buying the pregnancy test?
Anders Story (McManus 160)
How does Aubrey get into the Catmint House?
Through an open window (McManus 287)
Who is the person that is disguising themselves as Mildred Story?
Theresa Ryan (McManus 290)
Who does Jonah get a postcard from in the end of the book?
Paula Ryan (McManus 321)
Who is the only person Aubrey is able to text when she leaves the house to confront Mildred?
Archer Story (McManus 273)
What does Allison hear Adam say at the beach?
"The world would be better without them in it" referring to Matt and Kayla (McManus 248)
Where does Allison find Adam and Anders on the night of the party?
On the pier/dock (McManus 285)
What does Milly take from Jonah in order to figure out who he really is?
His drivers' license/His wallet (McManus 86)
Who interviews the cousins about their families?
Hazel Baxter-Clement (McManus 127)
What is Milly's full name?
Mildred Margaret Story-Takahashi (McManus 9)
Who does Matt choose over Allison?
Kayla Dugas (McManus 244)
Where does Allison go to tell Mattt about the pregnancy?
Arabella's Coffee Shop (McManus 242)
What does Milly's watch have engraved on it?
Omnia vincit amor/Love conquers all (McManus 167)