Belly
Clue: Played by Lola Tung, Belly finds herself in a dramatic love triangle between Conrad and Jeremiah, two brothers with this last name.
Clue: Before she starts dating Steven, Taylor has a brief, dramatic summer romance with this aspiring indie-rock musician and competitive debater.
Clue: Jeremiah is heartbroken when he discovers Belly has secret feelings for this brooding older brother of his.
Response: "Who is Conrad?"
Clue: Throughout the series, Steven shifts from being a protective brother to a romantic partner for this best friend of Belly.
Clue: After graduating from high school, Conrad leaves Cousins Beach to attend this prestigious Ivy League university in Rhode Island.
Introduced in the first episode, Belly has a lifelong obsession with this marine animal, owning a stuffed toy version named Junior Mint.
"What is a polar bear?"
A massive Swiftie, Taylor choreographs a dance routine for herself and Belly to this specific upbeat Taylor Swift song in Season 2.
"What is 'Delicate'?"
Jeremiah is known for mixing this specific, brightly colored beverage for the house, which he refers to as his signature drink.
"What is a Shirley Temple?"
Clue: During a high-stakes night at the country club, Steven loses a massive chunk of his hard-earned tip money playing this casino card game with wealthy members.
Conrad steps away from the beach to teach Belly the basics of this sport, which he plays competitively in school.
"What is football?"
Evoking her childhood summers at Cousins Beach, this three-word code phrase is frequently shared between Belly and her mother, Laurel.
"What is 'Lemon Jelly Belly'?"
In a memorable Season 2 confrontation, an exasperated Steven proves how well he actually knows Taylor by correctly shouting out this middle name. [1, 2]
"What is Madison?"
According to family lore, Conrad maliciously tricked a young Jeremiah into leaving the crust on his sandwiches by telling him it would prevent this physical trait. [1]
"What is curly hair?" (Conrad wanted the sandwiches for himself, and Jeremiah desperately wanted straight hair). [1]
In the first novel by Jenny Han, Steven is completely absent from the main summer drama because he leaves Cousins Beach early to do this with his dad.
"What is go on a road trip to visit colleges?" (or "What is visit colleges?")
Though the show changes his habit to weed, the original Jenny Han books feature a stressed-out Conrad constantly hiding away to smoke this specific substance.
"What are cigarettes?" [1]
In the Season 2 finale, the show breaks its tradition of using Taylor Swift songs for Belly and Conrad's big moments, instead playing this 2013 Beyoncé track while Belly kisses Jeremiah in a motel parking lot.
"What is 'XO'?"
In Season 2, Taylor steps up to help Belly raise money to save the Cousins Beach house by entering them into a competitive boardwalk dance-off at this specific retro arcade venue.
"What is Golf 'N Stuff?"
Proving he has known her his whole life, Jeremiah correctly remembers that this is Belly’s absolute favorite flavor of candy from the breakdown lane gas station.
"What is Sour Cherry?" (Specifically, Sour Cherry Laffy Taffy/bites). or sour patch kids is wut I remember
While visiting Steven at Princeton University in Season 2, Belly and Jeremiah end up crashing a party hosted by this specific, real-life elite student dining club that Steven is trying to impress.
"What is the Cap and Gown Club?"
During a devastating Season 2 flashback, Conrad and Belly share a romantic winter getaway to the Cousins Beach house, where Conrad introduces Belly to this unique, double-sweets snack combination.
"What are hot cocoa and Swedish Fish?"
Though usually working out their differences on the sands of Cousins Beach, an high-stakes, multi-episode arc in Season 2 forces Belly, Taylor, Steven, Jeremiah, and Conrad to team up and illegally break into this specific local venue overnight.
(Think about it for a few seconds...)
"What is the Cousins Beach Country Club?" (Acceptable: "What is the Country Club golf course/boardwalk venue?")
🌊 Why it fits:
If you are finalizing your trivia night, do you need help structuring the final point values, drafting a tie-breaker clue, or organizing the rules for the players?