Democracy is stronger when everyone participates.
Quality of participation matters more than quantity.
Citizens should have the freedom to participate or not. Forcing political participation undermines individual autonomy.
Democracies already require citizens to contribute to collective systems (taxes, obeying laws, jury duty in some countries).
Democracies require citizens to contribute, not just receive benefits. Society already requires participation in collective systems (following laws, paying taxes, education).
Voting is fundamentally different from taxes or legal obligations.
Choosing not to vote can itself be a political statement.
Citizens can still submit a blank ballot, spoil their ballot, or formally abstain.
Elections become more moderate when the entire population participates.
Compulsory voting creates uninformed voting. Mandatory turnout may lead to random, protest, or low-quality voting.
Voluntary voting does not guarantee informed voting either. When turnout is broad, campaigns shift from mobilizing loyal supporters to explaining policies to ordinary citizens.