Break a Leg
The way Jenny broke her arm when she was a kid
Fell out of a wagon
Month of Jenny's birthday
March
Nail polish color that was used on Andrew's toenail as a baby
Blue
Names of the 2 children who broke Catie's birthday figurines while Jill was babysitting
Will and Margaret
Number of stitches Sean Bobby received in his chin
Six
Exact date of Jenny and Barry's engagement
December 22, 2018
Food item Ella hid under her bed as a child
Fluff
Name of the child who was caught peeing in the sink while Jill was babysitting
Will
Child who fell out the front door at Julie's and got road rash all over their face
Ella
Name of street Jenny lives on
Maplewood Ave
Phrase Catie was overheard saying when she first met Tom
"Tom...he's such a bad guy"
Name of child who had a hole in her shirt after a cow bit her at the farm
Maggie
Item removed from Maggie's nose by Dr Feldman at age 2
Popcorn kernel
Name of the college Jenny graduated from
U Mass Lowell
First concert for Catie Maggie and Ella
Taylor Swift
Catie was videoed saying this name (one of Julie's friends) in her best Boston accent
Jen Bernard
Child who woke up with swollen lips when sick with pneumonia
Ella
Emoji like item Bob drew on Jenny's cast while she was sleeping when she broke her arm
Smiley Face
Julie Egan's current age
46
Name of the 2 children involved in the infamous underwear swap at the duck boats
Will and Maggie