Trades
The Giants acquired Carlos Beltran as they looked to repeat, what the Mets acquired was an underrated pitcher that was slotted behind deGrom and Thor for years.
Zack Wheeler
While he became a decent utility hitter, this switch hitting former #1 prospect left the Rangers with nothing but disappointing.
Jurickson Profar
This Make-Belief slugger was a legend back in MLB The Show 16, and has yet to make an appearance since.
Reggie Stocker
2011 AL Winner
Texas Rangers
Despite hitting .300 with a .374 on-base and 129 RBI's, this slugging 1st Basemen finished 2nd behind Dustin Pedroia in the 2008 MVP voting.
Justin Morneau
The Mets gave up future Rookie of The Year Michael Fulmer to Detroit to acquire this Cuban Slugger back in 2015.
Yoenis Cespedes
While he became a serviceable veteran for a little while, this 2004 Top 5 Prospect never lived up to fellow pitchers near his ranking, such as Greinke and Hamels.
Edwin Jackson
Back in MLB The Show 17, SDS would drop two "bosses" for each type of program. When they released the Hardware "bosses" it revealed Jimmy Rollins and who?
Tim Lincecum
2007 NL Winner
Colorado Rockies
Despite a career season from this Ace, he stood no chance as Justin Verlander took home the 2011 Cy Young unanimously.
Jered Weaver
Looking to rebuild, the Pirates traded former MVP Andrew McCutchen to the Giants and acquired this All-Star outfielder.
Bryan Reynolds
With guys like Ohtani, Vlad Jr, and Acuna ahead of this middle infield prospect, this 2017 Top 10 Prospect has yet to prove anything in Colorado.
Brendan Rodgers
This fan favorite card was amongst the cards in the Ticket Counter back in MLB The Show 17, as this switch hitting postseason goon could not get out.
Carlos Beltran
2005 NL Winner
Houston Astros
Despite an incredibly historic season in 2015, this right hander fell short to a 2nd half surge from Jake Arrieta.
Zack Greinke
With the Dodgers looking to upgrade the hot corner, they acquired Casey Blake from the Indians. However, they gave up a future All-Star and an On-Base machine.
Carlos Santana
In 2010, the only prospects rated higher than this lefty pitcher prospect for the Orioles were Heyward, Strasburg, Stanton, and Posey. His near 5 career ERA was incredibly disappointing.
Brian Matusz
This boss was the first Signature Series boss back in MLB The Show 19.
Madison Bumgarner
2008 AL Winner
Tampa Bay Rays
By far a career season, this right hander finished 3rd place in the 2016 NL Cy Young race, as Mad Max and his 284 K's were enough to get the job done.
Kyle Hendricks
The Padres looked to buff up their offense, acquiring Ryan Ludwick from the Cardinals. What they gave up in this three-team trade is what makes them shake their head.
Corey Kluber
Back in 2006, this #2 OF Prospect for the Marlins was slotted ahead of players such as Verlander and Lester. His .257 career average leaves a lot to be desired.
Jeremy Hermida
Back in MLB The Show 18, the Immortals needed player programs to make progress, and for Ken Griffey Jr., his program needed Larry Doby and what other CF?
Duke Snider
2002 NL Winner
San Francisco Giants
Final Jeopardy: Final Outs
In the historic 2004 season, the Red Sox emerged from a 3-0 deficit and ended up sweeping the Cardinals in the World Series. "Back to Foulke" is the famous line, but who hit it to Foulke?