The first Thanksgiving supposedly had these unexpected guests.

Soup hater
Who is Jared?
H
What is Hydrogen?
God created the earth in this many days
What is 6?
Usually gets stuffed
What is turkey?
The first Thanksgiving was located here.
Where is Plymouth, Massachusetts
Lightweight
Who is Ethan?
Si
What is Silicon?
The number of tribes in Israel
What is 12?
Feels like concrete when it hits your stomach
What are mashed potatoes?
This President refused to recognize Thanksgiving?
Who is Thomas Jefferson?
Cat got your tongue?
Who is Tyler
Kr
What is Krypton?
The most wicked King of Israel
Who is Ahab?
This dish has elevated canned soup sales by 40%
What is green bean casserole?
The first Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade happened this year (get within the decade)
When is 1924?
Hughhhh Hughhhh
Who is Jacob
W
What is Tungsten?
These two people did not die
Who is Enoch and Elijah?
This food is also known as dressing
What is stuffing?
This president received a raccoon as a Thanksgiving gift.
Who is Calvin Coolidge
Why I oughta
Who is Piper?
Tm
Thulium
This book of the Bible was written without explicitly mentioning the name of God.
What is Esther?
Bourbon is a semi-common ingredient in this dish