Eilu Metzios 23 24 25 review

Mr. Expert

100

Rashba 

כד

200

סימן הבא מאליו

כג.

300

story of Biran River

כד:

400

מקום הוי סימן או לא הוי סימן

כב:

כג:

500

Don't touch 

כד.  

כה:

Whats the Answer

100

but their are Goyim??

גוים חיישי לכשפים

200

Let the piece of meat be the Siman??

בדאיכא סימנא בפסקא

300

Both Halachos???

לפנים משורת הדין

400

but its the tide of the river??

Biran river is different bec. it has obstacles 

500

רבה היכי מתרץ לה ורבא היכי מתרץ לה

Raba- the siman by alumos is the tag

Rava - the siman by alumos is the place

Reverse

100

in a city that doesnt have animals 

but there are animals??

200

its common weight 

let the weight be the siman?

300

if one found it in a shul or a bais medrash 

did Rashba say his halacha even by majority jewish area? do we follow rashba?

400

our mishnah is talking about flax

our -Mishnah said fruits next to a basket- KEEP

the Braisa said fruits next to a basket-ANNOUNCE

500

our mishnah is talking about  cups and barrels 

Mishnah said found a vessel covered- dont touch

Braisa said found vessel covered- announce 

When

100

announce it even without a siman

a place with תלמידי חכמים

200

keep it even with a siman

saved from a lion, tide of sea, etc.

300

put it in a drawere

an item with a siman in a majority non jewish area 

400

money announce it (2 possibilities)

stacked

biran river 

500

you return  the כלי and fruits 

1- flax

2-some fruits left in the basket

3-fruits facing the basket 

4- basketis empty but it doesnt have  a rim