P1P Discord GotYs:
1980-1984
P1P Discord GotYs:
1985-1989
P1P Discord GotYs:
1990-1994
P1P Discord GotYs:
1995-1999
P1P Discord Games
of the Decade
2023

1980 Game of the Year was:

BattlezoneMystery House
BezerkPac-Man
Crazy ClimberRally-X
Missile CommandRogue


Runner-Up: Rally-X

2023

1985 Game of the Year was:

Commando
Super Mario Bros.
Gauntlet
Ultima IV
Paperboy
Where itWi Carmen Sandiego?
Space Harrier
Winter Games


Runner-Up: Space Harrier

2023

1990 Game of the Year was:

Dragon Quest 4
Mega Man 3
F-Zero
The Secret of Monkey Island
Final Fantasy III (JPN)
Super Mario World
Gargoyle's Quest
Wing Commander


Runner-Up: The Secret of Monkey Island

2023

1995 Game of the Year was:

Chrono Trigger
Tetris Attack
Mario's Picross
Time Crisis
Panzer Dragoon
Warcraft II
Suikoden
Yoshi's Island


Runner-Up: Panzer Dragoon

2023

Game of the 2010's Was:

Alan Wake
Persona 5
Last of Us
Portal 2
Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild  
Super Mario Odyssey
Mass Effect 2
Xenoblade Chronicles


Runner-Up: Last of Us

2023

1981 Game of the Year was:

Defender
Scramble
Donkey Kong
Tempest
Frogger
Ultima
GalagaWizardry


Runner-Up: Galaga

2023

1986 Game of the Year was:

Bubble Bobble
Metroid
Castlevania
Out Run
Dragon Quest
Space Quest
The Legend of Zelda
Star Soldier


Runner-Up: Metroid

2023

1991 Game of the Year was:

Civilization
Sonic the Hedgehog
Final Fantasy IV
Street Fighter 2
Zelda: A Link to the Past  
Streets of Rage
Monkey Island 2
Super Castlevania IV


Runner-Up: Street Fighter 2

2023

1996 Game of the Year was:

Civilization II
Pokemon Red & Blue
Mario Kart 64
Super Mario 64
Panzer Dragoon II Zwei  
Super Mario RPG
PaRappa the Rapper
Wave Race 64


Runner-Up: Super Mario RPG

2023

Game of the 2000's was:

Bioshock
Persona 4
Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker  
Portal
Metal Gear Solid 2
Resident Evil 4
Metroid Prime
Super Mario Galaxy


Runner-Up: Bioshock

2023

1982 Game of the Year was:

Dig Dug
Q*Bert
Ms. Pac-Man
Robotron: 2084
Pitfall
Tron
Pole Position
Ultima II


Runner-Up: Pitfall

2023

1987 Game of the Year was:

Final Fantasy
Phantasy Star
Maniac Mansion
R-Type
Mega Man
Sid Meier's Pirates!
Metal Gear
Zelda 2


Runner-Up: Phantasy Star

2023

1992 Game of the Year was:

Dragon Quest V
Streets of Rage 2
Final Fantasy V
Sonic the Hedgehog 2
Indiana Jones & the Fate of Atlantis  
Super Mario Kart
Lunar: The Silver Star
Super Mario Land 2


Runner-Up: Dragon Quest V

2023

1997 Game of the Year was:

Castlevania: SotN  
Goldeneye 007
Diablo
Gran Turismo
Final Fantasy VII
Jedi Knight
Final Fantasy Tactics  
Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon


Runner-up: Final Fantasy VII

2023

Game of the 1990's was:

Chrono Trigger
Super Mario 64
Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past  
Super Mario World
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Super Metroid
Metal Gear Solid
Yoshi's Island


Runner-Up: Chrono Trigger

2023

1983 Game of the Year was:

Elevator Action
Star Wars (Arcade)
Nobunaga's Ambition
Track & Field
Planetfall
Ultima III
Spy Hunter
Xevious


Runner-Up: Track & Field

2023

1988 Game of the Year was:

Blades of Steel
Mega Man 2
Blaster Master
Ninja Gaiden
Contra (NES)
Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA)
Dragon Quest 3
Wasteland


Runner-Up: Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA)

Bonus Winner: Super Mario Bros. 3 after everyone forgot it came out in 1988 in Japan

2023

1993 Game of the Year was:

Castlevania: Rondo of Blood  
NBA Jam
Doom
Phantasy Star IV
Gunstar Heroes
Secret of Mana
Link's Awakening
Simcity 2000


Runner-Up: Secret of Mana

2023

1998 Game of the Year was:

F-Zero X
Panzer Dragoon Saga
Half-Life
Radiant Silvergun
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time  
Soul Calibur
Metal Gear Solid
Starcraft


Runner-up: Metal Gear Solid

2023

Game of the 1980's was:

Contra
Simcity
The Legend of Zelda  
Super Mario Bros.
Metroid
Super Mario Bros. 2
Punch-Out
Tetris


Runner-Up: Super Mario Bros.

2023

1984 Game of the Year was:

Drug Wars
Kung-Fu
Elite
Marble Madness
The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
Summer Games
Karateka
Wild Gunman


Runner-Up: Summer Games

2023

1989 Game of the Year was:

Castlevania III
Simcity
Ducktales
Super Mario Land
Final Fantasy Legend
Tetris (GB)
Phantasy Star 2
Wonder Boy III: The Dragon's Trap


Runner-Up: Simcity

2023

1994 Game of the Year was:

Donkey Kong (GB)  
Super Metroid
Castlevania: Bloodlines  
Super SF 2 Turbo
Final Fantasy VI
TIE Fighter
Lunar 2: Eternal Blue
Warcraft


Runner-Up: Donkey Kong (GB)

2023

1999 Game of the Year was:

Crazy Taxi
Street Fighter 3: Third Strike
Gran Turismo 2
Super Smash Bros. (N64)
Mario Golf (GBC)  
System Shock 2
NFL Blitz 2000
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater


Runner-Up: Mario Golf (GBC)

2023

Game of the 1970's was:

Asteroids
The Oregon Trail
Breakout
Sea Devil
Colossal Cave Adventure  
Space Invaders
Combat
Zork


Runner-Up: Breakout