Identifying Central Ideas
Objective Summary
Source Credibility
Biased vs. Unbiased Writing
CRAAP
100

Central idea is just another way to say ___ idea

Main idea

100

An objective summary SHOULD NOT include what in it? NO O_______!

No Opinions!

100

Who would be more credible if investigating a fight at school: 

the group of student bystanders recording or the teacher who watched the fight start? Why? 

The teacher watching knows the beginning, middle, and end of the situation. They are also are a trustworthy source with no reason to lie. 

100

What does bias mean? 

Bias =a strong preference/opinion for or against something, someone, or a group, usually in a way that is unfair, one-sided, or closed-minded.

100

What does CRAAP stand for? 

Currency, Relevance, Accuracy, Purpose

200

What's the main idea? 

Deep-sea diving is dangerous for humans because of freezing temperatures and crushing water pressure. Today, scientists use unmanned robot submarines called ROVs to explore the deep ocean floor. These robots can stay underwater for days to film sea life and collect soil samples. By doing the dangerous work that humans cannot survive, ROVs have helped scientists discover a brand-new world at the bottom of the sea. 

Robot submarines help scientists safely explore and study the deep ocean

200

Summarize the beginning, middle, and end objectively: 

Central Valley High School plans to get rid of nutrition break in favor of adding a student study hall in the middle of the day. This would improve student grades and focus. Opposers of this say that this change would shorten the school day and be counterintuitive. 

Beginning: A student study hall in the middle of the day has been proposed to replace nutrition break. 

Middle: The purpose is to improve focus and grades. 

End: Not everyone agrees because the change would still shorten the school day. 

200

You are writing an article about caring for houseplants. Determine if the source is relevant only, credible only, is both credible/relevant, or neither. 

"The Top 10 Hard to Kill Houseplants" image found on Instagram







Relevant only, not credible

200

What is their opinion (bias) about AI?

"The panic over AI stealing human jobs is completely ridiculous. Automation is nothing but a massive upgrade for our society. AI will liberate workers from boring, repetitive tasks and open up millions of highly creative tech roles. Anyone complaining about job loss is simply refusing to adapt to the obvious future of human progress." 

AI is something good that we should accept for society's progress forward. 

200

Why do we CRAAP test websites/sources?

To check their credibility

300

What's the main idea?

"The ancient Romans are famous for their military power, but their true genius lay in their engineering. Across Europe, the Romans constructed massive aqueducts—stone bridge structures designed to transport fresh water from distant mountain springs directly into crowded cities. These water systems relied entirely on gravity, sloping downward by just a few inches every hundred feet to keep the water flowing smoothly over dozens of miles. This reliable supply of clean water allowed Roman cities to build public baths, fountains, and sewer systems, which drastically improved public health. The creation of these aqueducts proved that Roman engineering was essential to supporting and expanding their vast civilization."

Roman aqueducts were engineering successes that brought fresh water to cities and supported the civilization.

300

Summarize the beginning, middle, and end of this objectively: 

Polar bears hunt for seals on thick sea ice in the Arctic. As the Earth grows warmer, though, sea ice gets thinner. With less stable ground, some hungry polar bears search for food inland, often dangerously close to human environments. Although polar bears usually keep to themselves, a very scared or angry one could attack and even eat a human. 

Beginning: Warm weather causes ice to melt and polar bears to move. 

Middle: The bears come closer to human land for food. 

End: Bears can potentially hurt humans nearby. 

300

Can you use an article without an author? Should you? What would you need to do instead to cite it? 

Yes, and you can but you need to use the title in your citation and make sure it is credible otherwise

300

Does this article seem neutral when looking at the author and word choice? Explain.

"Our city council is wasting time debating a new park when our downtown economy is dying. Shoppers are abandoning local businesses because they cannot find any place to park. Building a park will only attract loiterers and garbage, whereas a new parking garage will immediately bring thousands of paying customers to our stores. The choice is obvious if we care about the survival of our city." -Business Owner

No, the business owner would be against a park being built and uses words like "wasting time" and "obvious", which are biased/opinionated. This makes the source not informative/credible.

300

What part of CRAAP does an article fail if it was published in 2005?

Currency

400

What's the main idea? 

 "Honeybees are vital to global agriculture, pollinating about one-third of the food we eat, including fruits, vegetables, and nuts. However, these essential insects are facing a crisis. Over the past decade, billions of bees have died due to a combination of habitat loss, pesticide use, and climate change. Without bees, farmers would struggle to grow crops, and grocery stores would face massive food shortages. Protecting bee populations is no longer just an environmental issue; it is a direct threat to the global food supply."

Honeybee populations are declining, which threatens the stability of the global food supply.

400

Write a brief objective summary of this text.

Journalism experts agree that citizen journalism is the collecting and reporting of information via social media, public platforms, and traditional news outlets, either by non-traditional sources or the public. For example, police officers or city clerks could operate as citizen journalists if they were to release information about an incident. Citizen journalism has become increasingly popular with the rise in popularity of smartphones. However, an early example of citizen journalism can be found as far back as 1963. 

Citizen journalism is when everyday people share the news on public or social platforms.

Even city officials can be citizen journalists. 

People did this before smartphones, but smartphones made it much more common.  

400

A student is writing a research paper on the health benefits of a plant-based diet. They find an article titled "The Green Shift" published on a popular fitness blog. The article claims that cutting out meat cures chronic diseases, citing testimonials from three social media influencers. Choose the credibility:

  • A. The source is highly credible because it focuses exactly on the student’s topic of plant-based diets.
  • B. The source is not credible because it relies on personal testimonials instead of peer-reviewed medical data.
  • C. The source is credible because social media influencers are relatable experts for modern teenagers.
  • D. The source is not credible because fitness blogs are never allowed to be used in high school research papers.

B. The source is not credible because it relies on personal testimonials instead of peer-reviewed medical data.

400

Reword this into unbiased writing:

"Our city's brilliant mayor easily crushed her weak and clueless opponent in the election."

The mayor won the election against their opponent.

400

Look at this website URL. What part of CRAAP would this fail? http://www.puppiesforsale.com/blog

Authority (author/publisher/organization is not a .gov or .edu website and is a blog, not credible)

500

Based on this text, what's the central idea? 

In the 15th century, European countries began sailing the world, searching for new lands and resources. Europeans wanted to extend their power and influence across the globe and achieve glory. They also sought new resources, like gold, to increase their prosperity and riches. Italian explorer Christopher Columbus sailed for the Spanish crown in search of a new water route to India. Many European monarchs funded and sponsored the voyages of explorers to engage in the lucrative trade in Asia. In 1492 Columbus hit land he thought was India, but in actuality was the Caribbean in the Americas.

The main idea is Christopher Columbus was apart of European exploration into the Americas in order to find new resources.

500

Write an objective summary of the text:

Perhaps the most significant development in the story of conquest and warfare is the use of gunpowder to propel a deadly object toward a chosen mark. Although history tells us it was the Chinese who developed this deadly weapon, the Europeans would jump on the technological band wagon, using it to devastate the natives of the New World during the Age of Exploration.

The creation of gunpowder allowed bullets to be shot at targets now. The Chinese created it but Europeans are known for using them on Native Americans during the Age of Exploration. 

500

A student is researching the daily lives of enslaved people in the American South before the Civil War. They find a diary entry from 1852 written by a wealthy plantation owner. In the diary, the owner writes that the workers on his plantation are "happy, well-fed, and deeply content with their labor." 

  • A. The source is highly credible because it is a primary document written during the actual time period being studied.
  • B. The source lacks credibility because a diary is a private document and cannot be trusted for historical facts.
  • C. The source is biased because a plantation owner has a clear interest in making slavery look positive and humane.
  • D. The source is credible because plantation owners were the only people educated enough to keep accurate records.
  • C. The source is biased because a plantation owner has a clear interest in making slavery look positive and humane.
500

Reword this into unbiased writing:

"The committee barely had to glance at the test scores from Ceres High and Central Valley before deciding that Central Valley was superior in every possible way."

The committee determined Central Valley's scores were higher than Ceres High. 

500

What is the purpose of an article titled "The Benefits of including AI in Schools" written by Elon Musk (a founder/CEO for an AI company). How does he benefit from publishing this article? What is his goal? 

Purpose - to implement or sell his AI technology to schools and have more people using it