Scenarios
Definitions
Wild Card
Which leader is most effective?
Panelists
100

Joe wanted to leave work early because he had a long week and wanted to get a head start on resting. He felt like, despite not finishing his tasks, that his boss would allow it. His boss rarely had anything positive or negative to say, and just as Joe suspected, he was given permission to start his weekend early. 

Laissez-faire Leadership

100

One individual makes decisions unilaterally, with little or no input from others.

Autocratic Leadership

100

2004

The year that Youth Action was founded

100
Leadership style is most effective when leading a group of highly skilled individuals who are able to work independently and don't require as much 1:1 management

The Chill-o-crat

100

This public servant is considered a "democratic leader" because they have to consider the thoughts and opinions of many others before making a final decision. 

Councilmember Anthony Phillips

200

Mary believed she had a good idea about how to best complete the project. However, her group leader insisted that following the correct procedure would render the best results. The leader decided to ignore Mary's idea in favor of the given instructions. 

Bureaucratic leadership

200

Strong emphasis on rules, procedures, and hierarchical structures and focus on ensuring that operations and tasks are carried out according to established policies, protocols, and regulations.

Bureaucratic leadership

200

1.53 million

The population of Philadelphia

200
Leadership style is most effective when the easiest way to complete a task is by following the directions as closely and accurately as possible. 

The Bureacrat

200

This officer of the law is considered an "autocratic leader" because they have a lot of power in their position to make lasting, impactful decisions. 

Judge Karen Simmons

300

A group of teens quickly realized that there were not enough beds at the cabin they rented for the weekend. The group leader was responsible for asking 2 people to leave, so they decided to have 1:1 conversations with each guest. Only after they had a talk with each guest did they ask Simon and Taylor to leave. 

DemoCratic leadership

300

A hands-off approach, allowing team members significant freedom in making decisions and carrying out tasks.

Laissez-faire Leadership

300

78 years

Donald Trump's age

300

Leadership style is most effective when trying to lead a group of unskilled people, whom you cannot trust to work independently, towards completing an urgent task.

The Autocrat

300

This panelist would not be considered a laissez-faire leader, as their continuous insight and attention is critical to their job function. 

Judge Karen Simmons

400

Susan was onboarded to her new job in the middle of a turbulent time for her company. Her boss mentioned an important project that her and the other new hires would be expected to help out with. However, when Susan finished her training 2 weeks later, she learned that her boss finished the entire project alone.

Autocratic leadership

400

Leader actively involves team members in the decision-making process and emphasizes collaboration, open communication, and shared responsibility.

Democratic Leadership

400

$6.2 billion

Philadelphia's 2024 operating budget

400

Leadership style works best when leader does not have all the answers, and is working with a team of capable people who can responsibly make important decisions.

The DemoCrat

400

This panelist is the opposite of a "bureaucratic leader", as they have consistently blazed their own path and have made a career out of compelling Black women and girls to do the same. 

Melonie Butler