Case Evidence
What was the name of Simon Kelleher's notorious app?
About That
What specific item was intentionally removed from the nurse's office right before Simon's fatal allergic reaction in detention?
Every single EpiPen
Who was suspected of making the EpiPens disappear from where in the school?
Since Addy had visited the nurse's office and the EpiPens had gone missing that day, she was a big suspect in the investigation.
What genre does 'One of Us Is Lying' belong to?
Young Adult Mystery
What critical piece of evidence did Addy find in Jake's room that proved his involvement in Simon's plan?
Simon’s encrypted manifesto / Reddit comment history saved on his computer (or draft posts from About That).
Who is the main officer involved in the investigation of Simon's death?
Officer (Hank) Budapest
Who are the Bayview Four?
Bronwyn Rojas, Nate Macauley, Cooper Clay and Addy Prentiss.
Who is the real villain in One Of Us Is Lying?
Jake Riordan
Who actually killed Simon Kelleher?
Simon killed himself. He orchestrated his own suicide to frame the Bayview Four as the ultimate revenge scheme, with Jake helping carry out the aftermath.
What event leads to the detention of the five Bayview High students in 'One of Us Is Lying'?
They were found with phones in Mr. Avery's lab, which is strictly forbidden.
What substance was found in Simon's water that led to his death in 'One of Us Is Lying'?
Peanut oil
What did Simon say his role is in this whole scheme?
"The omniscent narrator"
What happens to Simon during the detention in 'One of Us Is Lying'?
Simon falls to the floor, wheezing and asking for his EpiPen.
Who actually staged the car crash outside the classroom window during detention, and why?
Sam Devereaux & Val Chandlan. They were paid by Simon (and Jake) to cause a distraction so Simon could drink water spiked with peanut oil.
Which TV show portrays the investigation and publicizes it to the whole country?
Mikhail Powers Investigations