On-Case AFF
In your own words, what is the AFF's plan
The United States federal government should create hybrid licensing requirements and guidelines for the use of copyrighted material for training and output of non-commercial and commercial generative artificial intelligence.
What is the NEG response to the Journalism Advantage
Journalism isn't key to Democracy
What is the Sci Research DA in simple
Copyright will limit Scientific Research
What is title, author name, and year?
The volume with which you need to speak.
What is loud?
What are the two advantages of the Copyright AI AFF
Journalism
Model Collapse
According to the NEG files, does democracy solve war AND Why is that answer significant to the case
NO - Doorenspleet '24
Harms the AFF impact argument
In terms of the DA, what is "fair use"
"Fair use" is a concept in copyright law that allows people to use parts of copyrighted work without needing permission from the copyright owner. I
How you know it's an inherency card.
What is if it describes the status quo (what's currently wrong)?
The tone of voice you should have. (Monotone or Inflected)
What is with emphasis/inflections?
What is the Impact Argument AFF will make
Loss of Democracy & Rise in Autocracy
Tag: Journalism Erosion of Democracy in the US causes global rise in autocracy and World War 'Etchenique 23
Do you really know what model collapse is? If so, explain it to an elementary school student
Yes, when a computer program that learns from data stops being good at learning new things and just keeps giving the same answer over and over, even if the answer is wrong. It happens because the robot (or model) gets "stuck" in a certain way of thinking, and it can't improve anymore, even t
How you know it's a solvency card.
What is if it describes how the plan will solve the harms?
What you'd have if you actually read your file.
What is an understanding AND an ability to respond effectively in cross examination?
Sum the ENTIRE AFF in your own words
The response must include these 5 components:
Plan
Advantage 1
Advantage 2
Solvency
Impact
Make a They Say argument about AI Licensing & Respond Example: They say... but we prove that...
They say AI needs to be licensed in order to save jobs (Coffey & Smith 23) BUT we say Licensing is impossible because the scale is too large (Damle 23)
What is the AFF response to the Sci Research DA
Licensing will help Sci Research, research isn't key to sci progress, Sci research is declining
What needs to be in a DA.
What is link, uniqueness, and impact.
Parts of a rebuttal.
What is minimal cards, analytics, line by line, impact calculus?
What is the most popular author/tag in the AFF
Lynch 24'
(I'll also accept Coffey & Smith)
According to NEG what is the threat of licensing (Impact)
Absolution Turn (The turn outweighs the case—the tech industry is more powerful and will negotiate on their terms—only protecting the value of human journalism solves :Lessin 2)
Tell me the Impact Story of the DA
An impact (definition regarding both sides) AND a good example.
The harm if the plan is accepted (neg), the harm if the plan isn't accepted (aff). Ex. up to interpretation