Horror Made Wholesome
Creep It Real
Cider? I Hardly Know Her
100

A concerned mother hires a pair of enthusiastic church officials to help her energetic daughter find her voice and get a bit of bed rest.

What is The Exorcist?

100

If you say her name three times into a dark mirror, this legendary, vengeful spirit is rumored to appear covered in blood.

Who is Bloody Mary?

100

This autumnal overachiever is orange, round, and somehow gets invited to every fall party.

What is pumpkin?

200

A friendly man returns to a neighborhood after a long absence to help local teenagers realize that dreams can come true.

What is Nightmare on Elm Street?

200

In 1967, two men supposedly captured a 59-second film reel of this furry bipedal cryptid walking through a forest in Northern California.

What is Bigfoot?

200

You can drink it hot, cold, spiced, or spiked—but please don't ask grandma which version she prefers.

What is apple cider?

300

A dedicated hotel caretaker spends a peaceful, snow-bound winter with his loving family doing indoor crafts like typing and maze exploration.

What is The Shining?

300

Translated as "goat-sucker," this spike-backed creature from Latin American folklore is blamed for the mysterious, bloodless deaths of local livestock.

What is the Chupacabra?

300

It's crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, and spends every Thanksgiving pretending it isn't just an excuse to eat butter.

What is a dinner roll?

400

A creative, artistic teenager gets a massive surprise at her high school prom when her classmates help her make a bold, unforgettable fashion statement.

What is Carrie?

400

Point Pleasant, West Virginia features a 10-foot chrome statue dedicated to this red-eyed, winged cryptid said to predict catastrophic disasters.

Who is the Mothman?

400

This sauce is tart enough to make you pucker but somehow still gets invited to the Thanksgiving table every year.

What is cranberry sauce?

500

A sweet, tech-savvy little girl loves sharing her favorite home videos on VHS tapes with anyone looking for a quick distraction.

What is The Ring?

500

While pop culture often incorrectly depicts it as a shapeshifter, this Algonquian spirit actually lures human prey into the woods by perfectly mimicking the voices of their loved ones.

What is a Wendigo?

500

This warm drink combines honey, lemon and usually whiskey or bourbon. Basically, it's a cocktail pretending to be medicine.

What is a hot toddy?