500
"Advanced"
Read the following letter a student wrote to a local newspaper.
Student Says “No” to School Uniforms
The following letter appeared in the Changing Times Weekly, a small-town
newspaper.
What’s the point of wearing school uniforms? I do not believe that uniforms make
students act better at school as adults say. What I wear does not make any
difference in how I behave. I am me, and I will act as I should no matter what I
wear. Whether I am in jeans and a T-shirt or a fancy dress, I am still the same
person.
Wearing a school uniform limits my creativity and my ability to be myself. I like to
be able to dress in ways that show who I am. Some days I am in a blue mood;
other days, I am in a red mood. I am never in a gray plaid mood! For this reason I
do not understand why I should have to wear gray plaid skirts and white blouses
every day.
Think about this question. When do adults ever have to wear uniforms? Adults
wear uniforms for some jobs such as those associated with the military, the food
service industry, or the medical field. However, most jobs do not require uniforms.
My friends and I all agree that school uniforms are not what we want for our
school. Please do not make the choice for us about what we wear. Instead, think of
another way to “make us act better” if you think that is the purpose for having us
wear uniforms.
Trenice Lasalle, 6th Grade
Sidney Middle School
Which of the following is a correct evaluation of Trenice’s use of tools of
persuasion to justify her purpose for writing the letter?
A. By exaggerating her different moods, the author establishes and supports a plan to
entertain the reader with interesting but not factual information about school
uniforms.
B. By comparing and contrasting adult uniforms and student uniforms, the author
establishes and supports a plan to explain to the reader the problems with asking
students to wear school uniforms.
C. By airing and rebutting the school’s reason for uniforms, the author establishes and
supports a plan to persuade the reader to agree that students do not need to wear
school uniforms.
D. By using the bandwagon tool, the author establishes and supports a plan to
persuade the reader that she is not alone in her ideas about school uniforms
What is
C. By airing and rebutting the school’s reason for uniforms, the author establishes and
supports a plan to persuade the reader to agree that students do not need to wear
school uniforms.