Directives and Standards
Review of O&M Examinations
Recommendation Categorizing
Recommendation Tracking
Recommendation Life Cycle
Not SMART Recommendations
100

This D&S is used as a catch-all for Review of O&M Program Examinations other than High and Significant Hazard Dams.

What is FAC 01-04, Review of Operation and Maintenance (RO&M) Program Examination of Associated Facilities (Facilities Other Than High- and Significant-Hazard Dams)?

100

This examination is used as a general assessment of the condition of pertinent features of a dam using a checklist developed specifically for that dam. 3 words

What is an Annual Site Inspection (ASI)?

100

This recommendation category involves the correction of severe deficiencies where immediate and responsive action is required to ensure structural safety, operational integrity of a facility, or operating personnel/public safety.

What is Category 1?

100

These offices are responsible for entering O&M recommendations into the Dam Safety Information System (DSIS) and tracking their status.

Who are the regional, area, and/or field office?

100

Under the Reclamation Transparency Act, O&M recommendations with an estimated total cost of over $100,000 are reported through this process to identify Reclamation-wide repair needs.

What is the Major Rehabilitation and Replacement (MR&R) activities list?

100

Patch the cracks and seepage locations along the outlet works conduit and reexamine the conduit every 3 years or whenever the reservoir rises above 2765 feet, for development of new seeps.

SMART: Identify the shortcoming in the Rec

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant,Timely


What is Attainable

As worded, this recommendation can never be completed.

200

Directives and Standards provide the level of detail necessary to ensure consistent application of Policy Reclamation-wide and can be found here.

What is Reclamation Manual?

200

These exams are performed every 8 years, alternating every 4 with Comprehensive Reviews (CR's) and conducted by the regional office.

What are Periodic Facility Reviews (PFR's)?

200

Recommendations covering less important matters but believed to be sound and beneficial suggestions to improve or enhance the O&M of the project or facility. If the recommendation is still applicable, the current year designation will be reassigned to this recommendation number.

What is Category 3?

200

Status updates on these recommendations will be provided by the responsible area manager and regional director within DSIS on an annual basis.

What is a Category 2 O&M recommendation?

200

Quarterly reports on the status of incomplete O&M recommendations are provided to the regional directors. The reports identify recommendations that are considered "planned". These two fields are required in DSIS to signify a recommendation is planned.

What are CUR_SCHED_COMP_DATE and EST_COMP_COST?

200

Repair and anchor the buoy line upstream from the overflow spillway crest.

SMART: Identify the shortcoming in the Rec

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant,Timely

What is Timely

Because completion of this activity is critical to public safety, recommendation statement should provide completion timeframe (e.g., before threat of spill).

300

This Directive and Standard covers the requirements for BOTH the Review of O&M Program for High and Significant Hazard Dams and the Safety Evaluation of Existing Dams (SEED) Program.

What is FAC 01-07, Review/Examination Program for High and Significant Hazard Dams?

300

Periodic recreation site examinations are performed by these Reclamation groups.

Recreation program managers, area and regional facility operations and maintenance staff

300

At Minidoka Dam modifications were made to address ice loading on the radial gates. This type of recommendation was made to initiate modification of the facility to address a state of the art issue with the design.

What is a Safety of Dams (SOD) recommendation?

300

This format is used for a facility O&M Recommendation ID.

What is YYYY-Category-Letter?
(Example: 2012-2-A)

300

A category 2 recommendation is made for an asset that has reached the end of it's usable life and needs to be decommissioned. These offices needs to be involved in the decommissioning to complete this recommendation. (3)

Who is facility operations and maintenance, real property office, and lands and realty?

300

Determine type of coating applied to penstock and jet-flow gates. Research repair options.

SMART: Identify the shortcoming in the Rec

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant,Timely

What is Measurable

Completion of recommended activities may be difficult to measure. Also, these activities should be done to inform a recommendation to clean and recoat the subject metalwork.

400

This responsible party is involved with implementing Directives and Standards.

Who is everyone?

400

In this year the Review of Operation and Maintenance (RO&M) Program was established to conduct periodic examination reviews and a field examination program to identify issues at an early stage to lengthen service lives of structures and lessen expenditures. 

What is 1948?

400

Replacing a critical cable to gate connection on a sluiceway at a Dam is this Category of Recommendation.

What is a Category 1 or a Category 2 O&M recommendation? The category will depend on the asset or component.

Group decides. Trick question? "critical" = cat 1? need more data? e.g. is there overtopping protection?

400

As of 2018, tracking of these types of O&M recommendations is a new requirement for High and Significant Hazard Dams.

What are all Category 3 O&M recommendations?

FAC 01-12 used to say "Cat 2", now says Recommendations.

400

Reclamation-wide there are this number of Category 1 O&M recommendations, which currently exist.

What is 5?
2012-South Coast Conduit System
2017-Langell Valley Irrigation District System
2018-Sumner
2019-Norman
2019-11WC0250 - West Canal, Lateral, W39.9 Bridge

400

Repair the air vacuum/air release valve for the 42-inch-diameter steel outlet works pipe No. 2.

SMART: Identify the shortcoming in the Rec

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant,Timely

What is Specific

Does 'repair' refer to protective coatings? Is the valve not seating properly? Something else?

500

Requirements for Standing Operating Procedures (SOPs), dam operating training, operating logbooks, gate exercising and testing, and related safety and security procedures are contained in this Directive and Standard.

What is FAC TRMR-66, Operating Practices and Procedures for High- and Significant-Hazard Dams (and other facilities, as applicable)?

500

This is the required frequency of Electromagnetic Inspections as a form of inaccessible feature examinations of Prestressed Concrete Cylinder Pipe (PCCP).

What is not required.

AFR examinations are required every 6 years under FAC 01-04; there is currently NO requirement for EM inspections of PCCP, but its GOOD idea on an approx. 6 year basis

500

In 2017, the Oroville Spillway failure resulted in significant economic damage and over $1 billion in repair costs. This recommendation type would be used to identify the potential for a spillway failure similar to the Oroville incident.

What is both Operation and Maintenance (O&M) and Safety of Dams (SOD) recommendations? Both are used to identify risk and reliability of facilities. A SOD recommendation may identify modifications related to a potential failure mode. Repeat O&M repairs and recommendations may identify systemic underlying facility issues which.

In addition to cultural factors, improper construction and non state of the art design may have been contributing factors 

500

Status updates on these recommendations will be provided by the responsible area manager/regional director within DSIS and to the Director (Policy) and the Director (Operations), every 6 months (January 1 and July 1) until completed.

What is Category 1 O&M Recommendation?

500

Reclamation tracks incomplete O&M recommendations at all facilities. The oldest recommendation that is currently incomplete was made in this year.

What is 1986?

Upper Colorado MIDDLE RIO GRANDE CONSERVANCY DISTRICT SYSTEM: Albuquerque Division - Perform an engineering study of the feasibility of automating the Angostura Diversion Dam bypass sluice gates.

500

Excavate rocks and soil away from the top of the left and right outlet works stilling basin walls.

SMART: Identify the shortcoming in the Rec

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant,Timely


What is Relevant

Intent behind this recommendation is not clear but is to provide the OSHA-required 42-inch height to prevent falls. This recommendation statement unnecessarily tells operating entity how to comply with the OSHA requirement.