What is false imprisonment?
Intentionally confining someone against their will
Assault test
The defendant intended to create the apprehension of contact;
Plaintiff has apprehension that physical contact was going to occur;
Apprehension was reasonable;
Contact must be imminent; and
Contact must be harmful or offensive in nature.
Defamation; what is libel? What is slander?
Libel = published and/or broadcasted (social media counts)
Slander = oral defamatory statements
*a dead person cannot be defamed
*a corporation/product can be defamed - called an injurious falsehood / slander of title
What is trespass to land?
Where a person, without legal justification, enters, remains in/on, or places an object in/on land occupied or possessed by another person
Intention is not required so long as the conduct was voluntary (ie. you step on someone’s land, thinking it was your own, it would count as trespass)
Defences to intentional torts
Consent = explicit or implied
Self-defence/defence of others =
action that one takes to protect themselves
The force used must be reasonable under the circumstances
The threat must be imminent
Must be of like force (cannot be excessive)
Defence of Property = minor use of force to remove someone from your property (ask first to provide an opportunity before using force)
Provocation =
is a partial defence; is kind of like a duty not to provoke someone
Is used if the self defence that was used was too excessive, they can say “I was provoked.”
Reduces the cost of damages that they owe the plaintiff, or the time they serve if it is a criminal charge
Limitation period
if the claim was filed outside of the limitation, the case is adjourned
Some torts do not have limitations as found in s. 16 of the Limitations Act
What is the difference between assault and battery?
Assault = The tortfeasor causes reasonable apprehension of contact for the plaintiff (no contact is required)
Battery = The tortfeasor makes contact with the plaintiff
Battery test
The defendant intended to touch or make contact with the plaintiff;
Contact was actually made with the plaintiff; and
Contact was unlawful, harmful, and/or offensive in nature.
Defamation test
Was the defendant’s statement made to a third party?
Is it specific enough that it can be inferred that it referred to the plaintiff?
Is it untrue or false?
It must lower the person in the estimation of right-thinking members of society (aka it makes the average person think ill of them).
What is nuisance?
Substantial and unreasonable interference with a person’s use or enjoyment of their land
Includes but is not limited to; negative effect on owner’s enjoyment of land, noise, excessive shade or light, odours, pollution, waterway diversion, projectiles, environmental protection legislation (can be codified)
What three damages are under Compensatory Damages?
Pecuniary (Special) Damages : Are quantifiable damages | Does not have a cap | Costs incurred to date | Estimated future costs | Done before the non-pecuniary cost
Non-Pecuniary (General) Damages : Cannot be quantified (ie. pain, suffering, quality of life) | Has a cap, as one cannot really compensate for everything | Done after pecuniary damages
Aggravated Damages : Not typical | The defendant’s conduct has been particularly high-handed or oppressive (the defendant was malicious)
What is malicious prosecution?
Where a criminal action is initiated against the plaintiff, with no reasonable or probable cause, and, with malicious intent
- the criminal action will resolve in favour of the plaintiff
Malicious Prosecution test
The defendant initiated or proceeded with a criminal proceeding against the plaintiff;
The proceedings were terminated in favour of the plaintiff;
There was an absence of “reasonable and probable cause” for bringing the proceeding; and
The defendant acted with malice or with a primary purpose other than that of carrying the law into effect.
Internet Harassment (new tort) test
Defendant maliciously/recklessly engages in communication so outrageous and extreme in degree as to go beyond all bounds of decency and tolerance;
The defendant intended to cause fear, anxiety, emotional upset, or to undermine the plaintiff’s dignity; and
The plaintiff suffers harm.
Direct and immediate interference with a person’s possession of a chattel, without the intention or effect of negating that person’s ownership of the chattel -> aka interfering with the ability to use your own things
Chattel = possessions that are moveable or transferable
What is punitive damages?
Meant to punish the defendant and act as a deterrent against egregious conduct
May be awarded where the defendant’s conduct is so malicious, oppressive, and high-handed that it offends the court’s sense of decency
Punitive is not compensatory
What is intentional infliction of mental suffering?
An intentional statement that is flagrant, outrageous, and glaringly false and is calculated to produce harm.
Intentional Infliction of Mental Suffering test
There is an intentional statement that is flagrant, outrageous, and glaringly false;
The statement must be calculated to produce harm; and
The plaintiff’s reaction is more than temporary upset (visible or provable).
Defences of defamation
Fair comment -> opinion, not motivated by malice
Absolute privilege: where free expression without fear of being sued is needed (parliamentary, judicial proceedings, solicitor-client communications)
Qualified privilege: where people need the ability to communicate freely to perform a duty -> made honestly, without malice, and circulated only to those with a right to know – a duty to report under legislation
Responsible communication: the statement was on a matter of public interest and it was made responsibly
What is detinue?
The unlawful detention of another person’s chattel that constitutes a continuous cause of action (ie. someone keeps something that belongs to you)
What are other (equitable) remedies (outside of paralegal scope)?
Injunction : Where a court orders a defendant to do or refrain from doing something | Ie. orders the neighbour to build a fence to keep in their chickens
Declaratory Order : Where a court makes a binding declaration of one’s party’s right | Ie. dispute over land is decided by declaratory order
What is conversion?
Interference with the goods of another, amounting to essentially depriving them of their ownership rights
Can include; taking, destroying, or using the goods in a manner inconsistent with the owner’s right of possession
Statutory benefits, KNOW THEM
SABS benefits -> anyone injured in a motor vehicle collision through their own automobile insurance policy -> paralegal scope
Tort damages are only available in a motor vehicle collision for plaintiffs with injuries that pass the threshold -> lawyer scope