A selective mute
Who is Mrs. Paddy?
Serial killer on the run from the cops
Who is Jonathon?
A dramatic critic
Who is Mortimer?
Alcoholic plastic surgeon
Who is Dr. Einstein (not the famous one) ?
Believes they are President Roosevelt
Who is Teddy Brewster?
Believes that his face is marred by a scar; concert pianist
Who is Jeff?
A U.S. Senator
Who is Titus Savage?
Attempted victim of Brewster sisters who narrowly escapes
Who is Gibbs?
Had a heart attack and inspired the Brewster sisters to murder
Who is Midgely?
Lieutenant and Chief of police
Who is Rooney?
Believes a baby doll is her child
Who is Florence?
A Judge
Who is Samuel Savage?
Killed by Jonathon
Who is Mr. Spinalzo?
Who Jonathon looks like
Who is Boris Karloff?
Becomes engaged to Mortimer
Who is Elaine Harper?
A Statistician
Who is Hannibal?
Runs Happy Dale Sanitarium
Who is Witherspoon?
Playwright of Arsenic & Old Lace
Who is Joseph Kesselring?
Reverend who lives next door to the Brewster family
Who is Harper?
Police officer who wants to write a play
Who is the (idiotic) O' Hara?
Jeff’s wife
Who is Mrs. Willie?
Has an acid burn on their neck
Who is Aunt Martha?
Police officer who might shoot themselves in the foot
Who is Klein?
Killed Mr. Hoskins
Who is Aunt Abby?
First dead man Mortimer discovers
Who is Mr. Hoskins?