Command & Control
What was the biggest leadership challenge at COP Kahler?
Maintaining control and communication in a remote vally with limited support
What terrain features restricted movement around Wanat?
Rugged mountains, narrow valleys, and limited access
What major error in intelligence affected Wanat?
Underestimating insurgent strength and their preparation for attack
What type of fire support was delayed but critical at Wanat?
Attack helicopters (AH-64 Apaches)
Why was OP Topside especially vulnerable during the attack?
It was exposed on high ground with incomplete defenses
Why was shared understanding critical in the Wanat fight?
It ensured U.S. and ANA forces coordinated under pressure despite chaos
Why was the delay in constructing COP Kahler significant?
It left soldiers exposed without adequate defenses during intial occupation
What types of intelligence were most lacking before the attack?
HUMINT and reconnaissance on enemy movements in the valley
Why were indirect fire assets limited initially?
Mortar pits and positions were incomplete due to construction delays
What protection measures were incomplete were incomplete at COP Kahler?
Fighting positions, barriers, and overhead defenses
How did remoteness of the Waygal Valley impact command decisions?
It slowed reinforcements and limited situational awareness from higher Headquaters
What was Operation ROCK MOVE?
The operation to establish COP Kahler near Wanat before Tak Force Duke relief
How did insurgents achieve superior situational awareness?
They used local support networks, surveillance, and knowledge of terrain
What sustainment challenges affected COP Kahler's defenses?
Delayed supply and construction materials limited defensive readiness
What key decsion increased vulnerability during the battle?
Occupying COP Kahler before construction was complete
What warfighting function is most tied to mission command?
Command & Control
How could maneuver planning have reduce vulnerability at OP Topside?
By reinforcing the position earlier or selecting a less exposed location
What role could HUMMINT have played in avoiding surprise?
Local informants may have warned of large scale insurgent build up
How did logistics delays affect survivability of the outpost?
Soldiers had fewer fortifications and weaker fighting positions at the time of attack
What awards and recognition highlight the valor at Wanat?
Presidential Unit Ciation 3, 3 Medals of Honor, 2 Distinguished Service Crosses, 26 Silver stars, 169 Purple Hearts
As a 2LT, what key leadership lesson about C2 do you take away from Wanat?
Build trust, communicate intent clearly, and adapt when isolatef from higher Headquaters
As a 2LT, how should you balance maneuver with enemy infiltration risks?
Always evaluate terrain for both friendly mobility and enemy approach routes
As a 2LT how would you improve intelligence preparation in a remote AO?
Build rapport with locals, conduct persistent recon, and intergrate multiple intel sources
As a 2LT, how would you prioritize sustainment planning in a remote outpost?
Secure supply lines early, stage materials forward, and ensure protection is in place before full ocupation
What is the single most important lesson for junior leaders from Wanat?
Always priortize force protection and defensive readiness before committing soldiers to a new position